Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

All manuscripts submitted to this journal undergo a rigorous review process to ensure academic integrity and quality. The stages are as follows:

  1. Initial Review: Every submitted article is first screened by the Editorial Board for basic requirements, including focus, scope, and plagiarism checks.

  2. Double-Blind Peer Review: Articles that pass the initial screening are sent to at least two (2) independent reviewers. This journal employs a Double-Blind Review process, meaning the identities of both authors and reviewers are kept confidential.

  3. Revision Stage: Reviewers' comments and suggestions are sent back to the authors for necessary revisions.

  4. Third Reviewer (Optional): In cases of conflicting recommendations between the initial reviewers or other specific considerations, the Editorial Board may appoint a third reviewer to provide a final evaluation.

  5. Final Decision: The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on whether to accept or reject the manuscript based on the reviewers' recommendations.

Reviewer Guidelines

To ensure a high-quality and timely publication process, please adhere to the following guidelines:

  • Scope Alignment: Please verify the manuscript’s alignment with the journal’s Focus and Scope before proceeding.

  • Preliminary Assessment: Determine if the article is scientifically sound and suitable for a full review.

  • Strict Standards: Do not hesitate to recommend a rejection if the manuscript does not meet the scholarly standards for publication.

  • Timeliness: Please complete your review within the specified timeframe provided in the invitation.

  • Constructive Feedback: Provide detailed, objective, and constructive comments to help authors improve their work.

Steps for Submitting Review Reports:

  1. Accept Invitation: Confirm your availability to review through the OJS dashboard.

  2. Download Files: Access the anonymized manuscript for evaluation.

  3. Evaluate: Use the "Track Changes" or "Comment" tool in MS Word for specific feedback within the paper.

  4. Review Form: Complete the evaluation form by:

    • Assessing each section of the article.

    • Providing a recommendation (Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject).

    • Writing your summary comments in the provided text box on the website.

  5. Upload & Submit: Upload both the commented manuscript and the completed evaluation form, then click "Submit" to finalize.